2014 WI 3

 

CASE DISPOSITION OF PETITIONS
TO WISCONSIN SUPREME COURT

 

DECIDED November 1, 2013 to December 31, 2013

 

PETITIONS FOR REVIEW GRANTED

 

Docket No.                        Title                                                                                                 Date

 

2011AP1653-CR

State v. Carlos A. Cummings

12/17/2013

2011AP2548-CR

State v. Luis M. Rocha-Mayo

11/21/2013

2011AP2868-CR

State v. Clayton W. Williams

11/21/2013

2011AP3007-CR

State v. Derik J. Wantland

11/21/2013

2012AP46-CR

State v. Jimothy Jenkins

12/16/2013

2012AP55

State v. Andres Romero-Georgana

12/19/2013

2012AP320

Sharon R. Waranka v.
Wadena Insurance Company

11/20/2013

2012AP378-W

Lorenzo D. Kyles v. William Pollard

12/17/2013

2012AP393-CR

State v. Cortez Lorenzo Toliver

12/17/2013

2012AP520-CR

State v. Adrean L. Smith

12/17/2013

2012AP580

Russell Adams v. Northland Equipment Company, Inc.

11/20/2013

2012AP584-AC

League of Women Voters of Wisconsin Education Network, Inc. v. Scott Walker

11/20/2013

2012AP1047

Asma Masri v. State of Wisconsin Labor
and Industry Review

11/13/2013

2012AP1307-CR

State v. Jeremiah J. Purtell

11/20/2013

2012AP1582-CR

State v. Andrew J. Matasek

11/20/2013

2012AP1644

Rachelle R. Jackson v. Wisconsin County Mutual Ins. Corp.
Prosser, J., did not participate.

11/26/2013

2012AP1967

Data Key Partners v. Permira Advisors LLC

12/16/2013

2012AP1769-CR

State v. Martin P. O’Brien

12/05/2013

2012AP1770-CR

State v. Kathleen M. O’Brien

12/05/2013

2012AP1863-CR

State v. Charles E. Butts

12/05/2013

2012AP2140-CR

State v. Angelica C. Nelson

12/16/2013

2012AP2185-CR

State v. James R. Hunt

12/17/2013

2012AP2196

Jim Weissman v. Tyson Prepared Foods, Inc.

12/16/2013

2012AP2557-CR

State v. William F. Bokenyi

12/06/2013

2013AP221

Dow Family, LLC v. PHH Mortgage Corporation

 

12/16/2013

PETITIONS FOR REVIEW DENIED

 

Docket No.                        Title                                                                                                 Date

 

2010AP1535-CR

State v. Paul J. Esau

12/16/2013

2010AP1601

Juneau County Little Yellow Drainage District v. Krizan

Roggensack, J., dissents.

12/06/2013

2010AP1622-CR

State v. Javier Reyese Otero

11/26/2013

2010AP2447-CR

State v. Mack Lewis

11/26/2013

2010AP2516-CR

State v. Leshurn Hunt

11/26/2013

2010AP2910-CR

State v. Michael R. Leppert

11/26/2013

2010AP3069

State v. Joshua T. Howard
Abrahamson, C.J., dissents.

11/20/2013

2011AP891-CR

State v. Timothy D. Moseley

11/21/2013

2011AP892-CR

State v. Timothy D. Moseley

11/21/2013

2011AP1028-CR

State v. James E. Emerson

11/26/2013

2011AP1249

State v. Joseph J. Jordan

12/16/2013

2011AP1615-CRNM

State v. Rafael N. Bouldin

12/16/2013

2011AP1765-CR

State v. Anthony Darnell Little

11/26/2013

2011AP1923

State v. Antonio T. Maddox
Abrahamson, C.J., dissent.

11/20/2013

2011AP2091-CR

State v. Jeffrey J. Walker
Abrahamson, C.J., Bradley, J., dissent.

11/21/2013

2011AP2213

Jeffrey Erbs v. Mary Ann Erbs

11/26/2013

2011AP2357

Westrich v. Memorial Health
Center Inc.

11/20/2013

2011AP2471

State v. Armando P. Rodriguez

11/26/2013

2011AP2797-CRNM

State v. Frank R. Blumberg

11/26/2013

2011AP2798-CRNM

State v. Frank R. Blumberg

11/26/2013

2011AP2802-CR

State v. Gary L. Klotz
Bradley, J., dissents.

 

11/21/2013

2011AP2823-CR

State v. Michael Lyle Girard

12/16/2013

2011AP2831

Cheryl Cody v. Target Corporation

11/26/2013

2011AP2838-CR

State v. Brandon J. Murray

12/06/2013

2011AP2862

State v. Loren L. Leiser

11/26/2013

2011AP2863

State v. Loren L. Leiser

11/26/2013

2011AP2881

State v. Chad J. Lurvey

11/26/2013

2011AP2930-CR

State v. Michael T. O’Haver

11/26/2013

2011AP2955-CR

State v. Sergion Cazares-Herrera
Abrahamson, C.J., Roggensack, J., dissent.

 

12/05/2013

2011AP2960-W

Jermaine M. Webb v. Jeffrey Pugh

12/16/2013

2011AP2973-CR

State v. Willie H. Jackson
Abrahamson, C.J., Bradley, J., dissent.

 

11/20/2013

2011AP2974-CR

State v. Willie H. Jackson
Abrahamson, C.J., Bradley, J., dissent.

 

11/20/2013

2011AP2989

State v. Robert Lee Artic, Sr.

12/16/2013

2012AP24

Edward Wall v. WERC

11/26/2013

2012AP46-CR

State v. Jimothy A. Jenkins

12/16/2013

2012AP71-CR

State v. Alexander Jerome Wiley
Abrahamson, C.J., and Bradley, J., dissent.

11/20/2013

2012AP114

State v. Earl DeWayne Phiffer

12/16/2013

2012AP120-CRNM

State v. James Jermaine Davis

11/26/2013

2012AP244-CR

State v. Robert T. Warriner

12/16/2013

2012AP296

Dannelle Young v. Catharine Persinger
Abrahamson, C.J., Bradley, J., dissent.

11/20/2013

2012AP345-CRNM

State v. Randall Blue

12/16/2013

2012AP420-CRNM

State v. Tyrone L. Howard

11/26/2013

2012AP424

Kees v. Northern States
Power Company
Bradley, J., did not participate.

11/26/2013

2012AP447-CR

State v. Marcus D. Jackson

12/16/2013

2012AP480-CR

State v. Philip Steven Mora

12/16/2013

2012AP505-CR

State v. Tavoris A. Murphy Sr.
Abrahamson, C.J., dissents.

11/20/2013

2012AP542

Dorothy Beaver v. Exxon Mobil Corp.

Prosser, Roggensack, J.J., dissent.

 

12/06/2013

2012AP642-CR

State v. Brandon J. Murray

12/06/2013

2012AP646

State v. Stephanie M. Przytarski

12/05/2013

2012AP661

Chase Home Finance, LLC v. Nasman

12/05/2013

2012AP727

Douglas V. Erdman v. State of Wisconsin, Dep’t of Transportation

11/26/2013

2012AP747

State v. Toby Hill

12/16/2013

2012AP759

State v. Gregory A. Koleske

12/16/2013

2012AP760

State v. Gregory A. Koleske

12/16/2013

2012AP761

State v. Gregory A. Koleske

12/16/2013

2012AP801-CR

State v. Walter V. Rupar, III

11/26/2013

2012AP823-CR

State v. Ervin Thomas

11/26/2013

2012AP834

State v. Dwayne Almond

12/16/2013

2012AP848-CR

State v. Marvin E. Gilliom, Sr.

12/16/2013

2012AP853-CR

State v. Geometry L. Milton

12/16/2013

2012AP912

Waterstone Bank, SSB v. American Family Mutual Ins. Co.

11/26/2013

2012AP928-CR

State v. Maurice Collins

11/26/2013

2012AP929-CR

State v. Ronnie L. Thums

12/16/2013

2012AP970-CR

State v. Chad Jorgensen

11/26/2013

2012AP1027-CRNM

State v. Steven M. Stathas, Jr.

11/26/2013

2012AP1052-CR

State v. Wayne E. Williams

11/26/2013

2012AP1068-CR

State v. Mark J. Peterson

11/26/2013

2012AP1079-CR

State v. Roy H. Beals

11/26/2013

2012AP1090-CR

State v. Dezaray M. Colyer

11/26/2013

2012AP1118-CR

State v. Sean D. Patrick

11/26/2013

2012AP1119-CRNM

State v. Antonio Lamar Tatum

11/26/2013

2012AP1137-CR

State v. Eugene L. Cherry
Prosser, J., did not participate.

11/26/2013

2012AP1170-CR

State v. Gregory J. Copeland

11/26/2013

2012AP1176

Margaret Bach v. County of Milwaukee

11/26/2013

2012AP1194-CR

State v. Al A. Holifield

11/26/2013

2012AP1265

RBF, LLC v. DDB Limited Partnership

11/26/2013

2012AP1300

Ronald J.R. v. Alexis L.A.
Abrahamson, C.J., Bradley, J., dissent.

11/21/2013

2012AP1317-CR

State v. Stacy Bernard Campbell

12/16/2013

2012AP1339-CR

State v. Robert J. Betters

12/16/2013

2012AP1398-CR

State v. Andrew R. Ballenger

11/26/2013

2012AP1413

State v. Stephanie M. Przytarski

12/05/2013

2012AP1442-CR

State v. Elixavier Pacheco

12/16/2013

2012AP1443

State v. Reginald M. Clytus

12/16/2013

2012AP1445

State v. Roderick L. Harris

11/26/2013

2012AP1450-CR

State v. Derrique A. Brown

11/26/2013

2012AP1451

State v. Tammy S. Camden

11/26/2013

2012AP1457-CR

State v. London Mack Stewart

11/26/2013

2012AP1465

State v. Daniel W. Urbschat

11/26/2013

2012AP1482

Mattfield v. PHH Mortgage Corporation

11/26/2013

2012AP1495

State v. Derwin Dewayne Jones

11/26/2013

2012AP1513

U.S. Bank National Association v.
Bobbie R. Webber, Jr.
Roggensack, J., did not participate.

 

12/16/2013

2012AP1521

Christine Ready v. GGNSC Holdings, LLC

12/16/2013

2012AP1528

Orlando Residence, Ltd. v.
Kenneth E. Nelson
Prosser, J., did not participate.

11/26/2013

2012AP1542

Bernard Tocholke v. Shereen Tocholke

11/26/2013

2012AP1558-CR

State v. Bryan J. Stanley

11/26/2013

2012AP1578-CR

State v. Susan E. Krueger

12/16/2013

2012AP1691-CR

State v. Keith M. Bohannon

12/06/2013

2012AP1708-CR

State v. Antoine O. Henry

12/16/2013

2012AP1711-CR

State v. Robert Ladaniel Rogers

12/16/2013

2012AP1721-CR

State v. Vidal D. Mason

Bradley, J., dissents.

 

12/16/2013

2012AP1758-CR

State v. Nicholas Stone

12/16/2013

2012AP1759

Anna Kedinger v. Terry Strook

11/26/2013

2012AP1800-CR

State v. Denise A. Bilton

11/26/2013

2012AP1817

Poehling v. Trust Point Inc.

11/26/2013

2012AP1831-W

Justin L. Anderson v. Jeffrey Pugh

12/06/2013

2012AP1857

Charles S. McNeal v. David H. Schwarz

11/26/2013

2012AP1871

State v. Courtney Leon Cobbs

11/26/2013

2012AP1978-CRNM

State v. Devlon L. Driggers

12/16/2013

2012AP1988-CR

State v. Wesley Walter Maxcey

11/26/2013

2012AP1993

State v. Isaac Williams

12/16/2013

2012AP2009

State v. Lamont Elliot Moore

11/26/2013

2012AP2041

Botdorf v. Krebsbach

12/16/2013

2012AP2056

State v. Stephen M. Klatt

12/16/2013

2012AP2081

J&E Investments LLC v. Division of Hearings and Appeals

11/26/2013

2012AP2133

Citizens Bank of Mukwonago v. Edgewood Contractors, Inc.

 

12/16/2013

2012AP2184

Carey A. Molinski v. Chase Auto Finance Corporation
Prosser, J., did not participate.

11/26/2013

2012AP2255

Milwaukee Transport Services, Inc. v.
Labor and Industry Review Commission

11/26/2013

2012AP2256

Judith Pasko v. Milwaukee County

11/26/2013

2012AP2257

Robert B. Porth v. Milwaukee County

11/26/2013

2012AP2343

Elizabeth J. Redlin v. Northwest Airlines, Inc.

12/16/2013

2012AP2445-W

Eric Poirer v. Circuit Court
for Dodge County

 

11/26/2013

2012AP2508-W

Michael Lee Washington v. John D. Paquin

11/26/2013

2012AP2515-CR

State v. Ondrea Ray Matthews

12/16/2013

2012AP2531-CR

State v. William M. Grunwald

12/16/2013

2012AP2532

Marc A. Blanc v. City of Janesville

12/16/2013

2012AP2631-CR

State v. Gabriel Griffin
Roggensack, J., did not participate.

 

12/16/2013

2012AP2637

State v. Dennis C. Van Camp

11/26/2013

2012AP2683

Mitchell G. Zimmerman v.
David H. Schwarz

 

12/16/2013

2012AP2700

James Moser v. Anchor Bank FSB

12/16/2013

2012AP2720-NM

State v. Thomas H. Bush

11/26/2013

2012AP2737-CR

State v. Tareyton Pierson

11/26/2013

2012AP2747-CR

State v. John C. Broadnax

11/26/2013

2012AP2758

Michelle L. Paskiewicz v. American Family Mutual Ins. Co.

 

11/26/2013

2012AP2788

State v. Timothy C. Hagberg

12/16/2013

2012AP2789

State v. Timothy C. Hagberg

12/16/2013

2013AP40

Collett v. Richardson

11/26/2013

2013AP66-CRNM

State v. Brian A. Lawrence

12/16/2013

2013AP83

Barbara Singerhouse v. Charles Singerhouse

11/26/2013

2013AP356-W

Apollo C. Walker v. Judy P. Smith

12/16/2013

2013AP398

State v. Marvel L. Willingham

12/16/2013

2013AP433

Wells Fargo Bank N.A. v. Michael J. Harrop

11/21/2013

2013AP477

Marvin A. Prince v. David H. Schwarz

11/26/2013

2013AP569

Donald A. Waas v. Alan E. Ciche

12/16/2013

2013AP637

State v. Shipria C.

11/26/2013

2013AP638

State v. Shipria C.

11/26/2013

2013AP639

State v. Shipria C.

11/26/2013

2013AP666-CR

State v. Jeremy L. Jerome
Prosser, J., did not participate.

 

12/16/2013

2013AP778

Patrick J.T. v. Shelly S.
Abrahamson, C.J., Bradley, J., dissent.

11/20/2013

2013AP779

Patrick J.T. v. Shelly S.
Abrahamson, C.J., Bradley, J., dissent.

11/20/2013

2013AP871-CRNM

State v. Arthur F. Hill

11/26/2013

2013AP899

Ronald Terry v. Jim Schwochert

12/16/2013

2013AP936

State v. Roberta W.

12/16/2013

2013AP1028-W

Kenyatta S. Clincy v. Circuit Court for Milwaukee Co.

 

11/26/2013

2013AP1157

Ozaukee County Department of Human Services v. Callen D.M.

 

12/16/2013

2013AP1289

Ronald Schroeder v. Nicole Chaffee

12/16/2013

2013AP1373

Martens v. Vilas County

11/26/2013

2013AP1727-W

Scott R. Deichsel v. Timothy Douma

12/16/2013

2013AP1800-W

Moeketsi Molaoli v. Circuit Court for Rock County

12/16/2013

2013AP2194-W

Dezaray M. Colyer v. Denise Symdon

11/26/2013

PETITIONS FOR REVIEW DISMISSED

Docket No.                        Title                                                                                                 Date

 

2011AP758-CRNM

State v. Dennis J. Hiroskey

11/21/2013

2012AP2160

Dennis Lee Maxberry v. Keller Graduate School of Management

 

11/18/2013

2012AP2664

State v. Ervin Burris

11/25/2013

2013AP624

Margaret C. Vonfrick v. Robert H. Vonfrick

11/15/2013

2013AP893

City of Madison v. Ray A. Peterson

11/27/2013

2013AP1018-W

Robert Hammersley v. Circuit Court for Brown Co.

 

11/20/2013

2013AP1271-NM

State v. Shannon T.

11/20/2013

2013AP2117-LV

Waterstone Bank SSB v. Steven R. Schmidt

12/04/2013

 

PETITIONS BY COURT OF APPEALS TO CERTIFY

 

Docket No.                        Title                                                   Disposition                           Date

 

2009AP3073             State v. Michael R. Griep                          Denied                         11/20/2013

                                  Abrahamson, C.J., Bradley, J., dissent.

 

2012AP2115             Timothy Williams. v. Valued Services     Granted                       11/20/2013
                                   of Wisconsin LLC

 

2012AP2170             State v. Joseph J. Spaeth                            Granted                       11/26/2013

 

2012AP2499             Eileen W. Legue v. City of Racine             Granted                       11/26/2013

 

 

PETITIONS TO BYPASS COURT OF APPEALS

 

Docket No.                        Title                                                   Disposition                           Date

 

2012AP2571-CR               State v. Sean P. Tate                          Denied                        11/26/2013

                                          

                                          

COURT TAKES JURISDICTION ON OWN MOTION

 

Docket No.                        Title                                                   Disposition                           Date

 

2012AP1652                      Milwaukee Branch of NAACP         Granted                      11/20/2013
                                            v. Scott Walker

 

 

PETITIONS FOR AN ORIGINAL ACTION

 

Docket No.                        Title                                                   Disposition                           Date

 

2013AP1277-OA      Peterson v. PDQ Food Stores Inc.              Denied                       12/06/2013

2013AP1278-OA      Peterson v. PDQ Food Stores Inc.              Denied                       12/06/2013